The paper Similar Compositional Landscapes
in Ligeti and Webern is being considered for publication. This paper
compares similar approaches to composition from the composers
perspective with the aim of showing how initial choices, no matter how
seemingly trivial, greatly influence outcomes of artistic processes.
The following is a brief abstract:
Despite inhabiting radically different sound worlds, Ligetis Piano
Concerto and Weberns Symphony illuminate similar compositional
landscapes. In both cases, the composers decision to use strongly
characterized primitives limits the potential for large scale form in
both duration and complexity.
Generally, primitives, or small irreducible icons, are formed from shaped
raw material (isolated pitches, rhythms, timbres) which then become
generating mechanisms for the music (of a particular composition or
movement). The primitives, for both Ligeti and Webern, are strongly
characterized due to immediately perceptible constraints on material
identity (such as showing clearly the ordering of pitches in a row or
the use of recognizable scales and rhythmic patterns) and a high degree
of continuity (elements within the primitive bind together). This bestows
a clear precise identity to the music , but also limits its developmental
and formal aspects.